UK approaching a ‚return to east of Suez‘ decision

RUSI News, 29 Apr 2013-

The UK is approaching a decision point where a significant strategic reorientation of its defence and security towards the Gulf is both plausible and logical; and for the first time since the UK unceremoniously left the Gulf in 1971, a coherent strategy for a ‚return to east of Suez‘ is emerging, according to a new paper from the Royal United Services Institute (RUSI).

A Return to East of Suez? UK Military Deployment to the Gulf, by Professor Gareth Stansfield and Dr Saul Kelly, assess public statements which point to the current British government’s commitment to deepening the strategic defence relationship in the Gulf and argue the UK is taking on this burden both out of necessity and of desire.

The paper highlights the UK’s ‚return east of Suez‘ is more evolutionary than revolutionary and only partially related to the US pivot towards the Pacific. Stansfield and Kelly also suggest the UK ‚is giving renewed emphasis to its position in the Gulf in order to maintain the special relationship with the US‘ as well as engagement with the defence task in hand – namely deterring Iran.

‚Just as the UK’s withdrawal in 1971 created a security vacuum that drew the US, somewhat unwillingly, further into the affairs of the Gulf, the US’s cooling of its engagement seems to be drawing the UK back in,‘ write Stansfield and Kelly.

‚With the only remaining significant operation in which the US and UK work closely together coming to an unceremonious end in 2014, there is a clear need to ‚do something‘ if the strategy of being close to the Americans – in terms of political norms, military interconnectivities and global influence – is to be maintained.‘

The paper also addresses the considerable economic benefits, as well as the potential scale of the military deployment. The RAF is set to use the Al-Minhad air base in Dubai (currently used extensively in the logistics chain between the UK and Afghanistan) as a hub not only for the 2014 drawdown in Afghanistan, but as an overseas base of some standing in the future. The Royal Navy is also taking a more active interest in Bahrain, which is already home to the United Kingdom Maritime Component Command (UKMCC). Reports also suggest that senior army personnel are keen to build on their strong links with Oman. And the Emir of Qatar has reportedly been assured by Prime Minister Cameron of the UK’s commitment to the gas-rich emirate, with Doha a favoured location for UK military liaison and co-ordination activities in the Gulf.

‚We seem to be witnessing the slow transformation in the UK military posture towards a tentative return (at this early stage) to the pre-1971 strategy of rooting Britain’s presence in the southern Gulf through agreements with its traditional allies in Abu Dhabi and Dubai, with outlying anchors in Bahrain and Oman, and with close political and economic ties with Saudi Arabia and Kuwait that could be upgraded to the military level if necessary.‘

Professor Michael Clarke, RUSI’s Director-General, in his foreword to the study writes: ‚At a time of economic retrenchment and growing uncertainty within Europe, it may seem strange that the UK sees its future military security increasingly ‚east of Suez‘. Such an emotive phrase suggests imperial ambitions at a time when UK armed forces are smaller than they have been for 200 years. But there are compelling reasons for the UK to take its Gulf relationships much more seriously.‘

Professor Clarke warns, ’such a policy shift, if it becomes reality and is acknowledged, is not without its dangers. The military does not intend to ‚deploy‘ to the Gulf in any significant way, but it hopes to create the facilities to rotate back and forth; to pass through; to jump off from. Even so, this might represent more stretch on an already overstretched military establishment.‘

The paper also suggests there is significantly more at stake in this renewed relationship than mere military posturing: ‚By enhancing the UK’s relationships with the states of the southern Gulf, the UK is committing to the security and longevity of the Arab Gulf states – sheikhdoms which display only limited elements of democratisation (as understood in the West) and which have taken seemingly contradictory positions towards the Arab upheavals that spread across the Middle East since 2011, opposing the Shia revolt in Bahrain but supporting the Islamist revolutions in Tunisia, Libya, Egypt and Syria. The UK will also find itself very much on the fault line of searing sectarianism, between the Sunni and Shia worlds of Islam, that is increasingly defining the geopolitical landscape of Gulf and Middle Eastern security.‘

‚The UK could very quickly find itself with significant military forces based in one of the world’s most contested regional security complexes,‘ the study warns.

‚If the UK is serious in its reformulating its focus on the Gulf, once again, then a straightforward question needs to be answered: what is the strategic purpose of the return ‚east of Suez‘?‘

‚If it is to deter Iran, then this requires a strategy that is multifaceted and coalition-based, underpinned by the ready availability of a credible and significant military force. If it is only to strengthen the UK’s ties to the Arab Gulf states for a range of reasons including an increase in defence sales, trade and investment, then this should be acknowledged publicly and it should be explained that such limited engagements are necessary at a time when the entire region is in a state of political flux. The military-strategic and political lines of operation can be mutually complementary, but they need to be articulated as such in order to ensure a clear, readily understood British policy and strategy regarding the Gulf,‘ conclude the authors.

To read the briefing paper A Return to East of Suez? UK Military Deployment to the Gulf in full please visit http://www.rusi.org/EastofSuez

NOTES FOR EDITORS

1. Any enquiries and interview requests, please contact : Daniel Sherman / +44(0)20 7747 2617 begin_of_the_skype_highlighting +44(0)20 7747 2617 KOSTENLOS end_of_the_skype_highlighting / +44 (0) 7917 373 069 begin_of_the_skype_highlighting +44 (0) 7917 373 069 KOSTENLOS end_of_the_skype_highlighting / daniels@rusi.org

2. Professor Gareth Stansfield is the Al-Qasimi Chair of Arab Gulf Studies and Professor of Middle East Politics at the University of Exeter, where he is the Director of the Institute of Arab and Islamic Studies and Director of Research in the Strategy and Security Institute. He is also a Senior Associate Fellow and Director of Middle East Studies at RUSI.

3. Dr Saul Kelly is a Reader in International History in the Defence Studies Department, King’s College London at the Joint Services Command and Staff College, Shrivenham.

4. RUSI is an independent think-tank for defence and security. RUSI is a unique institution; founded in 1831 by the Duke of Wellington, it embodies nearly two centuries of forward thinking, free discussion and careful reflection on defence and security matters.

http://www.rusi.org/news/ref:N517AA3251F417/#.UX_eHG3wBLN

Advertisements